Comparison: Nails Inc – Baker st vs Sinful Colors – Endless blue vs Essie – Butler please

Hello lovelies,

What a week.  It has been really busy – even here.  I hope you had a great week but even more, a fabulous weekend planned. 🙂

I’ve been working with a beautiful blue and every time I go to grab for it, 2 others catch my eye and I can’t decide.  They all look so similar to me so I thought it was a great time for a comparison.  It’s been a while since I’ve done a comparison so I am happy. Let’s get to it.

On my pinky and index I have 2 coats of Nails Inc – Baker street.  On my middle nail I have 2 coats of Sinful Colors – Endless blue and on my ring finger I have 2 coats of Essie – Butler please. All are topcoated.  For me, Baker street and Butler please are almost exactly the same shade of blue. Without topcoat, Butler please dries with a very slight matte finish whereas Baker St is very shiny.  Endless blue is super super close to the others but I think there is a slight – super super slight – difference in the shade of blue.  I think you would only be able to tell if they are worn side by side and you are actually looking for it.  In my opinion, these 3 are so close to the same that you definitely don’t need all 3.  Let’s talk formula.  All of them applied really well.  I would have to say Essie – Butler please is the thinnest of them all opacity wise BUT it’s still pretty opaque.  I can’t really say any of these are bad but I think Sinful Colors – Endless blue is probably the most bang for your buck.  Either way, they are all beautiful and I am glad to have all 3 so that I can enjoy the blue goodness for longer 😉

 

What do you think? Do you have any of them?  Which one would you prefer?  Do you also think they are all very similar? This blue is just beautiful!!

Thanks for reading,